Just for clarification, I think that the AL central is the best division in baseball, easily. But as long as Kliger wants to argue about AL East vs. NL East, I’ll willingly punch holes in his argument. his arguments are in regular text, my response is in bold.
SS. I mean its not even close. AL East top shortstop: Derek Jeter. I think all of us would take Rollins, Reyes, Hanley Ramirez or even Renteria over Jeter. Ok. Done. Edge: Big NL Okay. first of all, if we are to do the All Star Team argument, you can only have one player at a position. So the AL east has Jeter and the the NL has Rollins. Both are lead-off men. Jeter’s average is .322, Rollins’s is .296. both of their OBPS’s are in the .800’s. Yes, Rollins has better pop, but Jeter gets on base more, and fields the shortstop position as well as anyone in the league. the NL does not have a big edge here at all. Edge: Slight NL
2B? Cano, Brian Roberts or Pedroia. I’ll take Chase Utley and Dan Uggla and be sitting pretty. Edge: Big NL Chase Utley, while he is the best second baseman in the leaugue, isn’t that much better than Cano. he had a .322 average and 22 homers, Cano had a .306 average with 19 homers. However, Utley has Ryan Howard protecting him in the lineup, and Cano has Melky Cabrera. Cano will only be getting better, but Utley, being 30 years old, is on the tail end of his prime. Edge: slight to moderate NL.
3B. A slight edge for the AL. It’s tough to top Rodriguez or Lowell, but Chipper and David Wright get closer than any one else. Edge: Slight AL No. Alex Rodriguez had 54 home runs and 157 RBI’s last year. his average is 11 points less than Wright but his OBP and Slugging percentage are higher, the latter being about 100 points higher. It is true however, that Wright showed lots of maturity and leadership during the Mets’s playoff run… oh wait. Edge: Biiiiig AL
1B. AL: No one. NL: Ryan Howard, Mark Teixiera. Edge: Big NL AL has no one? NO ONE? Carlos Pena would beg to differ, Kliger. his .282 average, .411 OBP and .627 OBP all are better than Ryan Howard’s numbers. Also he has one less homer and 15 less RBI. This can be attributed to him playing in a much less offense-friendly stadium and less volatile offense. Edge: Even
OF: AL: Manny, Rios, Wells. NL: No one. Edge: Big AL AL has Rios, Carl Crawford, and Manny. The NL has Beltran, Jeff Francouer, and… yeah. No statistical analysis necessary. Edge: Big AL
C: AL: No one. NL: Brian McCann. Edge: Slight NL sometimes I wonder if Kliger watches baseball. The AL East has Jorge Posada, fool! .338 average, 20 HR, and 90 RBI! McCann had .270, 18, 92. Jorge has an amazing plate-blocking ability as well. That average is positively ridiculous. Edge: Moderate AL.
We have to add a DH category, because in order to truly compare the leagues, you need the DH. playing baseball without a DH is like going to an NFC stadium and them saying, “we don’t use linebackers here.” So for the AL we have Papi, and we’ll pick the best hitter who is on the bench of an NL east team. Here is where we run into trouble. Cody Ross? So Taguchi? Nick Johnson? It doesn’t really matter. Edge: Monstrous AL.
SP: AL: Beckett, Wang, Halladay, Kazmir. NL: Santana, Hamels, Hudson, Smoltz. Edge: Moderate NL Let’s do this starter by starter.
Beckett v. Santana. Unless I’m mistaken, Johan was two games over .500 last year. Josh Beckett was Josh Beckett. Becks almost won the AL Cy Young, Santana did not. Edge: moderate AL
Wang v. Hamels: Similar numbers, Hamels has better ERA and much better SO, but striking people out isn’t part of Wang’s game. still, Edge: Slight to moderate NL
Halladay v. Hudson: Same numbers, Hudson has better ERA. Edge: Slight NL
Kazmir v. Smoltz: Smoltz had slightly better ERA, Kazmir had much more SO. However, Kazmir pitched for the Rays with those numbers, and Smoltz pitched for the Braves. These guys should both be pushed up to #2 on these lists, maybe Smoltz to #1. Edge: even to very slight AL.
I’m going to add a #5 starter, for the AL it is Jamie Shields and for the NL it would be John Maine. (I would do Pedro, but he’s a cockfighter, which oddly drew less attention than dogfighting. The “Oh, but it’s a cultural thing” excuse seems to work in this instance, even though it didn’t for Michael Vick. Maybe its because Vick is black… naww, there has to be some other reason.) Anyway, Maine’s ERA was 3.91 and he had 180 strikeouts. Shields was 3.85 and 184 SO. He will improve on those numbers this year. Edge: even to very slight AL.
RP: AL: Paplebon, Joba. NL: Wagner, Soriano. Edge: Moderate AL I’m breaking this into middle relievers and closers
Middle Relief:
AL: Hideki Okajima, Jeremy Accardo, Mike Timlin, Manny Delcarmen, Al Reyes
NL: Peter Moylan, Jon Rauch, Justin Miller, Aaron Heilman, Tom Gordon
Edge: I’ll give the AL a slight edge here because of Delcarmen and Accardo’s upsides.
Closer:
Papelbon v. Wagner: three blown saves vs. five blown saves. Pap had a much better ERA and more strikeouts in about 10 less innings pitched. He came up huge in the playoffs, and Wagner, obviously, did not. Edge: Moderate AL
lets tally up the scores:
Monstrous AL: 1
Big AL: 2
Moderate AL: 3
Slight AL: 2
Even: 2
Slight NL: 3
Moderate NL: 1
Big NL: 0
Monstrous NL: 0
Total AL: 8
Total NL: 6
Even: 2
If I weighted the bigger edges more than it would have been even farther apart. The AL east is easily better than the NL east. Kliger can argue all he wants, but he’s wrong.
- Levinger